Best Seafood Restaurants in Sewickley

A wonderful experience, as always. The care you showed to us for having both a birthday and anniversary was greatly appreciated. Our server was phenomenal, and very open to feedback when my husband's steak came out overcooked. She understood that it wasn't her fault, which we made sure to express multiple times! The manager was kind enough to remove it from the bill, despite providing another steak, and that was also greatly appreciated. Thank you very much for everything!

Number one our waitress (Bethany) was a delight. Very knowledgeable of the menu and provided attentive care and service. Food was phenomenal my lobster roll was a perfect crisp and buttery and the lobster mixed in with hot roll was perfection. Bread and carrot cake was absolutely ridiculous and we were informed that they were made in house by the pastry chef. Will definitely be back and bring more people.

My wife and I recently celebrated our first wedding anniversary by having dinner at Monterey Bay. As always, the food and experience were both exceptional. Further, our waiter, Giovani, provided what was quite possibly the best experience we have ever had in fine dining. His professional manner, attention to detail, menu knowledge, anticipation of our needs before we knew we needed them and his friendly and caring presence all contributed to an exceptional experience. We will absolutely be returning to dine at Monterey Bay and highly recommend anyone doing so ask for Giovani, as we will be. We also hope that management recognizes Giovani’s efforts and performance, as he managed to elevate our already stellar impression of Monterey Bay to our favorite dining experience.

Wonderful restaurant food is great , staff super nice, will definitely return!

What an absolutely amazing experience!!! It felt like walking into the grand ballroom on the Titanic with the incredible ornate ceilings and decadence everywhere. The food was beyond delicious and the service was impeccable which made for the ultimate birthday dinner. If you're celebrating a special occasion there is no place better than this!