18 Best Italian Restaurants In Rutland

18 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. Staci's

4.9

Exceptional(201)

$$$$

• Italian • Kettering

Booked 7 times today

Very nice food.polite staff.would definitely visit again

A photo of The Lair Restaurant & Bar Leicester restaurant

2. The Lair Restaurant & Bar Leicester

4.0

Excellent(129)

$$$$

• Italian • Leicester

Booked 2 times today

Mo and his team were amazing! There were 7 of us for an early dinner, including a 3 and 5 year old. Nothing was too much bother for these guys. Menu explained in full, recommendations made. Everyone's food was excellant. It's a long time since I received service of that standard. A fuss was made.of our grandson as it was his birthday. Little chocolate cake with a candle was organised, a lovely finishing touch. Perfect evening, thank you all. Dont change a thing!

A photo of Piccolino - Nottingham restaurant

3. Piccolino - Nottingham

4.5

Awesome(421)

$$$$

• Italian • Cotgrave

Booked 28 times today

After a bit of a poor start as quite a few dishes had sold out due to a big party they redeemed themselves and both the food and the service was excellent. Giovani did a fantastic job.

4. Softleys

4.9

Exceptional(883)

$$$$

• Italian • Hinckley

Booked 16 times today

From entering you are made to feel welcome, staff are attentive throughout, food is absolutely amazing, fresh produce and plenty of it. Great atmosphere too with gentle music in the background. Wonderful place and will be returning many more times.

A photo of Secret Garden Restaurant & Bar restaurant

5. Secret Garden Restaurant & Bar

(0)

$$$$

• Italian • Leicester

Secret Garden is Leicester’s premier restaurant, bar and lounge, offering an exceptional blend of authentic halal Italian cuisine, handcrafted cocktails, premium shisha and vibrant nightlife. Located in the heart of Braunstone Gate, our stylish venue combines elegant dining with a luxurious lounge atmosphere, creating the perfect destination for everything from casual dinners and romantic evenings to birthdays, celebrations and late-night gatherings. Guests can enjoy signature dishes including Seven Spice Lamb Chops, Gamberi e Basil Pesto Pasta, Rib-Eye Steak and our famous Secret Garden Wings, alongside a wide selection of cocktails, mocktails, premium spirits and desserts. With VIP booth seating, live DJs, themed events, private hire options and a sophisticated garden-inspired interior, Secret Garden delivers an unforgettable experience day and night. Whether you're joining us for food, drinks, shisha or a special occasion, where great food, great drinks and great vibes come together

A photo of The Italian Greyhound - Leicester restaurant

6. The Italian Greyhound - Leicester

4.8

Exceptional(2)

$$$$

• Italian • Oadby

Good service, Lovely food, And a great choice on the menu.

A photo of Merchant of Venice - Loseby Lane restaurant

7. Merchant of Venice - Loseby Lane

new

(0)

$$$$

• Italian • Leicester

Booked 10 times today

Experience authentic Italian dining at Merchant of Venice on Loseby Lane, Leicester. Located near Jubilee Square and Highcross Shopping Centre, our warm, elegant restaurant serves freshly prepared Italian food, handcrafted desserts, and artisan coffee in the heart of the city’s vibrant dining quarter.Known for its cosy atmosphere and Venetian-inspired hospitality, our branch is ideal for relaxed lunches, romantic date nights, and special occasions. We combine traditional recipes with carefully selected ingredients to create memorable meals. Whether you're exploring the city centre or searching for one of the top Italian restaurants in Leicester, enjoy authentic flavours and attentive service in a welcoming setting.

A photo of Merchant of Venice - Granby Street restaurant

8. Merchant of Venice - Granby Street

new

(0)

$$$$

• Italian • Leicester

Booked 7 times today

Located on Granby Street near Leicester Railway Station and the Curve Theatre, Merchant of Venice offers a warm, welcoming dining experience in the heart of the city. Inspired by traditional Venetian cafés, we serve freshly prepared pasta dishes, stone-baked pizzas, artisan coffee, and handcrafted desserts.Whether you are joining us for lunch, dinner, shopping breaks, or theatre shows, our relaxed city centre setting provides the perfect atmosphere for authentic Italian food. Focusing on quality ingredients and attentive service, we invite locals and visitors alike to enjoy a memorable meal for any occasion.

A photo of Albertinas Pizzeria restaurant

9. Albertinas Pizzeria

4.9

Exceptional(95)

$$$$

• Italian • Nottingham

Booked 5 times today

Amazing service, everyone was so friendly warm and inviting - brilliant cocktails and food too!

A photo of Montebello Ristorante - Horncastle restaurant

10. Montebello Ristorante - Horncastle

4.8

Exceptional(220)

$$$$

• Italian • Horncastle

Booked 11 times today

A fantastic lunch with excellent service definitely worth a visit.

Best Italian Restaurants in Rutland

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Award-winning

Accessibility

18 restaurants available nearby

1. Staci's

2. The Lair Restaurant & Bar Leicester

3. Piccolino - Nottingham

4. Softleys

5. Secret Garden Restaurant & Bar

6. The Italian Greyhound - Leicester

7. Merchant of Venice - Loseby Lane

8. Merchant of Venice - Granby Street

9. Albertinas Pizzeria

10. Montebello Ristorante - Horncastle

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable