Best Contemporary Italian Restaurants in Sheepshead Bay
Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Award-winning
Accessibility
13 restaurants available nearby
How are Featured results ranked
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- JJoshuaNew York City •2 reviews5.0Dined 1 day agoMy wife and I visited Cecconi’s to celebrate our 3rd wedding anniversary, and the entire experience was absolutely amazing from start to finish. The staff was super nice and went out of their way to make the evening special, seating us at a table with an incredible view that perfectly set the mood for the night. Every person we interacted with was incredibly welcoming, but they truly went above and beyond by bringing out our dessert with a special candle to surprise us for our celebration. We really appreciate the whole staff for making our milestone so unforgettable and would highly recommend this place to anyone!More infoCecconi's Dumbo$$$$• Contemporary Italian• DUMBO•4.4
- DdaleSan Francisco Bay Area •1 review5.0Dined 1 day agoVery interesting menu, everything was good and many dishes were standouts. the dim sum was a brilliant fusion dish, the reuben ravioli not as much but still tasty. My personal favorite was the lemon lemon lemon pasta -- how do they do it? Can't replicate this at home. Fluke crudo perhaps tied for first. You can get Portlandia-level backstories on the food if interested. If you love drinks spend time with the bartender and let her tell you what she knows about Amaro. Waitstaff uniformly lovely. Atmosphere lively, I would vote for a few softer surfaces to absorb the din, but we had no trouble enjoying great conversation with friends in a cozy booth. Everyone gets one!More infoCafé Mars$$$$• Contemporary Italian• Gowanus•4.9
- MmichaelNew York City •1 review5.0Dined on Oct 31, 2026Amazing food. 10/10 We will be back again and againMore infoZiggy's Roman Cafe$$$$• Italian• DUMBO•4.2
- SSaraGoldLas Vegas •14 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 26, 2026I appreciate the wonderful service that the waiter provided to me and the accommodations as well. This restaurant has a wonderful menu that includes all my favorite dishes such as minestrone soup, house salad and my spinach with garlic and mushrooms and onions. The veal Parmesan was so tender and has plenty marinada sauce and cheese. It was so delicious. It was plenty grilled vegetables. Ver tastyMore infoGargiulo's Coney Island$$$$• Italian• Coney Island•4.6
- TTelishaNew York City •1 review5.0Dined on Oct 24, 2026We were very happy we made the last minute reservation.More infoPatrizia's of Williamsburg$$$$• Italian• Williamsburg•4.6
Discover best Contemporary Italian restaurants in Sheepshead Bay
Discover the vibrant culinary scene of Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, with our curated collection of contemporary Italian restaurants. Nestled in this scenic waterfront neighborhood of New York City, these establishments offer a delightful blend of modern Italian dishes that cater to both traditional and innovative palates. Each restaurant showcases a commitment to quality and authenticity, featuring menus rich with fresh seafood, exquisite pasta dishes, and inventive Italian cuisine that reflect the dynamic food culture of the area. Patrons can expect top-notch service and an inviting atmosphere that complements the meticulously prepared dishes. As a hub for culinary creativity, Sheepshead Bay provides a unique dining experience, enhancing the charm of Brooklyn's diverse food landscape. Whether you're a local or a visitor, these contemporary Italian eateries promise an unforgettable gastronomic adventure in one of the city's most picturesque locales.