Best Restaurants with a Notable Wine List in New Buffalo

This was our first visit to Shaw's and won't be the last. We sat in the oyster bar and had a great time. The service was wonderful, the drinks were delicious, and the food was spectacular. Everything we had was delicious. West Coast oysters, calamari (best I've ever had), lobster roll, shrimp linguine, and key lime pie. Not a bad bite the entire meal.

Brewsters is always consistent and delicious. Our fav New Buffalo restaurant.

Went for a spontaneous weeknight dinner and like always, we were completely satisfied. Chris and Luis took excellent care of us. They are the best in the business for sure!

il Porcellino exceeded our expectations. Starting with the greeting from the host setting the tone making you feel welcome. The service was top notch, the food was excellent and the portions were large. To add to the evening the ambiance was cozy but lively.

Had a wonderful experience at Gibsons Italia! The food was delicious, and our waitress, Genevieve, was amazing. Her warmth and attentive service made the meal feel extra special by suggesting the two specials which were amazing. Great food is always a plus, but service like hers makes you want to come back. Thank you, Genevieve, for such a memorable visit!