Best Restaurants that are Worth The Drive in Shelter Island
Price
Cuisine
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
83 restaurants available nearby
How are Featured results ranked
Booked 47 times today
See what locals rave about
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- BBethanneNew York City •16 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoWe had a great meal at Noah’s. Everything was spot on- food, service, vibe. The autumn squash soup was a knockout- I could eat it every day. Loved the swordfish entree. Reasonable bottles of wine and delicious desserts. Highly recommend!More infoNoah's$$$$• Tapas / Small Plates• Greenport•4.5
- EEdwardNew York City •21 reviews5.0Dined 5 days agoFriendly service and outstanding mole. Definitely worth a return visit.More infoComomango Mexican Kitchen and Cantina$$$$• Mexican• Madison•4.5
- RRafaelNew York City •4 reviews5.0Dined 7 days agoFarm Country Kitchen was recommended by our daughter and worth the trip out East. Could use Bigger sign to locate restaurant but once found it was quite the ambience on the river. Great relaxed vibe and OUTSTANDING service. Food was quite delicious as well. Will definitely be back! thank you!!More infoFarm Country Kitchen$$$$• American• Riverhead•4.4
- DDebraGoldNew York City •63 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 28, 2026Roast chicken was out of this world! Can’t wait to come back again for it.More infoThe Old Mill$$$$• American• Mattituck•4.7
- SStephanieGoldNew York City •14 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 3, 2026What an incredible experience!! A must! I felt like I was in a movie having a little tea party! I believe it’s the owner served us. She’s incredible…. Beautiful memory I had with my family.More infoSpecialTea House$$$$• Afternoon Tea• Greenport•4.9