Best Historic Restaurants in West Milford

An excellent choice for our wedding anniversary dinner. There was a wedding reception in the main dining room, but we were seated in a smaller private room. We were well look after and served despite the wedding reception.

Beautiful inside and out. Service , quality and atmosphere was outstanding!

Outstanding, as always. Chef Dorian’s CRAB CAKES reign supreme. Outdone only by hospitality from Junior, Jacquie and Sara……….and Kevin’s #1, insane Martini. The best of Bergen County!! This team ROCKS!!!!!

We loved everything about this place ... transformed from a bank into a restaurant, it was the perfect atmosphere for dinner. We were seated by the "vault" which had gold bars stacked in it ... LOL! The waiter, Colby, was friendly and attentive. We shared the 8 hour octopus for an appetizer and my boyfriend had the lamb shank and I had one of the specials for the day, slow cooked pork ribs ... YUMMY! I had 2 lychee martinis, and he had a non-alcoholic beer called CONE HEAD ZERO which he says had a slight citrus taste to it. Overall, a great dining experience ... would recommend and come back again.

Excellent dining experience at Hapgoods! The Manager, Dan, was warm, professional and helpful and Sam our waitress was so helpful and welcoming as well. Great atmosphere. Nice outdoor dining option if desired and indoors had great ambience and good acoustics. Not too loud. Will return!