Best Restaurants for Special Occasions in Shelter Island / San Diego Bay

First time at this restaurant because we were in town of a birthday. Gorgeous views, great service and food was excellent. Do not hesitate if you are considering dining here, you will not be disappointed.

We were there for our 50th Anniversary. Our daughter recommended this restaurant to us. My wife and I had an outstanding experience at your restaurant. Our server was very attentive and efficient. He made our 50th memorable and exquisite. The food was outstanding with incredible flavor and presentation. Possible one of our most pleasurable dining experiences of our life. Thank you Herb and Wood.

From the moment you walk in and see the pasta being hand prepared in front of your eyes you know you’re in for a special culinary experience! Everything was so tasty from the roasted octopus appetizer to the fresh made lasagne. Service was excellent and the dining area is lively and true to Italian restaurants in Italy. Earns my Five Star Rating!!!

Great experience! The team at this place all work great together and provide great service all the way around. The lady that manages this place (Chelsea) seems very engaged and into her team providing the best experience for the customer. “It starts at the top” and it really reflects here. Our favorite restaurant by far!!!

We had an amazing experience, everyone from the owner to the entire staff was incredible. We highly recommend Barbusa.