Best Fine Dining Restaurants in Youngstown

Truly wonderful as always. Every detail on each dish is so well thought out. The chefs make dining here truly an exceptional experience! The Foie Gras PB & J was simply sublime. Perfect ambience, lovely staff. Thank you for always making dining here a delight!

Immaculate dining experience, delectable food, exceptional service. Hannah was my waitress my most recent visit, and she is an absolute doll, she was lovely to not only me and my company, but with her other tables as well.

Perhaps we've found a worthy, fine dining experience it the Warren, Youngstown Ohio area after all. For the most part, this area of Northeast Ohio is sorely lacking in restaurants that provide memorable food and a memorable experience. Not so at Gatsby's. Upscale ambiance, delicious food, great service and a very impressive wine list. Our server Makenzie (spelling?) and the wine steward, Brian delivered excellent, country club level service with just enough personal attention. The management stopped by our table when they learned this was our first time dinning. Very old-school and appreciated. We'd recommend the red meet here. The Wagyu beef filet and lamb chops entrees were in fact, memorable, along with the fine chocolate presented as an appetizer. Pricey here, yes, but worth it. We will return.

Great menu with many exceptional offerings. The wedge salad was one of the best I've had; very unique and flavorful. The filet with the crabmeat enhancement was delicious. The warm apple muffin dessert was sweet. Everyone in our party enjoyed their dinners and we look forward to visiting again.

Can’t wait to come back! Liam was great! Tina was very accommodating!