Best Date Night Restaurants in West Sayville

Tellers American Chop House is always a great dining experience. The food, atmosphere, and staff are a step above all the rest. Our waiter for the evening was Rob, who made the night that much more enjoyable. Recieved a birthday gift card to return from the manager who was so nice!

A wonderful experience. Everything from the food to the service to the view and the value for your money. There are many alternatives to dining by the water but this is by far the best.

Joelle is one of our favorite spots. Great food, great service, great staff. You all should try it!!!

Another great meal (2nd time eating here). I ordered the Prix Fixe Tuesday Special for $35 a four course meal starting with an exceptional Caesar Salad. It was followed by Vegetable Arancini, a breaded rice all filled with carrots, peas, onions and zuccchini(3 sizable breaded rice balls) drizzled with a marinara sauce. Delicious was an understatement. Dinner was a Blackened 6 ounce Salmon Filet in a Cajun Cream Sauce, served over wild rice and sautéed spinach that was fantastic. Dessert was NY Style Cheese Cake with whipped cream and a strawberry. My friend had Fish and Chips(Tater Tots) also reported as delicious. Atmosphere was lively and we could definitely hear our table conversation We were seated immediately by Jennifer who we met at the front desk. Great table location and she nicely pointed out the specials as the last time we were here it wasn’t a Tuesday so the Prix Fixe meal was not served. Jasmine did an awesome job as our server with her recommendations for dining as well. The menu is quite extensive and it will be great to come back again and sample something new. You won’t be disappointed and easy to get a reservation by calling or using Open Table.

Everything from drinks to entrees and everything in between was perfect!