37 Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Carroll Gardens

37 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

Icon

1. Gage & Tollner

4.7

Exceptional(476)

$$$$

• American • Downtown Brooklyn

Booked 86 times today

What an incredible find. This will be an annual visit for dinner when I come to nyc for work ! Loved every bite - beautiful oysters and incredible steaks and sides. An excellent wine list and a wonderful historic ambience ! Worth booking as it gets popular and for good reason !

2. Fraunces Tavern

4.6

Exceptional(3876)

$$$$

• Contemporary American • Financial District

Booked 160 times today

Exceptional dining environment and the quality of the service was top notch!

3. Verde on Smith

4.5

Awesome(683)

$$$$

• Italian • Cobble Hill

Booked 1 time today

The meal and service was great. Will definitely recommend this restaurant to my friends and family. Can’t wait to go again

4. Fragole

4.9

Exceptional(157)

$$$$

• Italian • Carroll Gardens

Booked 8 times today

Always a great dining experience at Fragole. Highly recommend ordering the Cavolo Nero salad to start: kale, apples, walnuts, cheese dressed with a creamy dressing is dynamite. For pasta: Rigatoni Firenze and Amatriciana, excellent. Just tried Chicken Cutlet Milanese, delicious. Tiramisu for dessert is amazing. Great wine list as well. Ambience, value and service keep me coming back!

5. Botte Brooklyn

4.4

Awesome(199)

$$$$

• Italian • Downtown Brooklyn

Booked 16 times today

Excellent service; savory and authentic plates; loved their kale salad and branzino was perfectly cooked. We'll go back!

6. Westville Dumbo

4.6

Exceptional(579)

$$$$

• American • DUMBO

Booked 11 times today

Loved the place FOOD AMAZING!!! Location in Dumbo wonderful. A small child was part of our party; she loved it! The staff went out of their way to make sure we had every thing we needed. did i mention the food? great breakfast!! cant wait to go back! thank you!!!

7. Balzem

4.6

Exceptional(733)

$$$$

• Mediterranean • NoLita

Booked 25 times today

There's a big difference between polite service and genuine hospitality. I love when the staff makes the whole experience feel personal, remembers the little things, and creates a welcoming atmosphere without trying too hard.

8. Wild Park Slope

4.7

Exceptional(113)

$$$$

• Italian • Park Slope

Booked 9 times today

Delicious brunch and incredible service! Everything from the appetizers to the mains, desserts, and cocktails is top notch. The fact that the entire restaurant is gluten free is simply an added bonus. The ambience is perfect for a catching up with friends, a date, or even young kids. Wild can really accommodate everyone. Highly recommend!

9. Tiny's

4.5

Awesome(1278)

$$$$

• American • TriBeCa

Booked 18 times today

Always wonderful, Kevin is the best! A hidden gem in Tribeca. Food and drinks on point, and the history of the place. You feel transported to another time and place.

Icon

10. Chambers

4.9

Exceptional(972)

$$$$

• American • TriBeCa

Booked 45 times today

Spectacular every time. Highlights of this visit were the 40 oz ribeye, the campo rosso chicories, cranberry beans, and, of course, the chocolate trifle for dessert. There's never a bad, or even a remotely disappointing bite. It's also so refreshing to dine somewhere that genuinely cares about offering thoughtful, balanced, surprising, and fun desserts. This was my fourth visit this year (Chambers is becoming a go-to spot for milestones and celebrations), and somehow the bread got even more perfect? A higher rise, a nuttier, toastier flavor from the sesame. A simple offering executed perfectly.

Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Carroll Gardens

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

37 restaurants available nearby

1. Gage & Tollner

2. Fraunces Tavern

3. Verde on Smith

4. Fragole

5. Botte Brooklyn

6. Westville Dumbo

7. Balzem

8. Wild Park Slope

9. Tiny's

10. Chambers

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable