Best Burgers Restaurants in Nutley

This was our third visit to this location, usually pre- and post-theater. It's a great value if you compare it to the restaurants we usually frequent and if you're just looking to fill your belly at a very pleasant venue, this could do the trick. We shared a Pastrami Reuben with an included side salad and an order of sweet potato fries. The sandwiches are usually big enough to share and we noticed several other couples doing the same. That could reflect the generous portions or the prices (around $25), maybe both. Service was very good. The place is lively and with good menu that reflects the name of the place. Kind of a marriage of diner and deli. With a cola and a beer, our bill came to about $50. We'd definitely recommend the Carnegie Diner and Cafe on Eighth Avenue. We may try another one of their locations next time.

The staff was excellent so welcoming and accommodating. Fun atmosphere and good food without breaking the bank. Great drinks also

Fantastic experience. Will do it again. Great, quick service. Great decor. Amazing.

Valentine's Day "Love Castle" experience was great! The dining area was decked out beautifully with decorations down to a candle on the table, balloons and bright festive garland. Our service was excellent. Our server, Cynthia, went above and beyond to make our experience special, including singing to us! She was especially attentive and very pleasant and has such a great personality! We would definitely go to the "Love Castle" event again!

Very cool. They did a great job preparing for Valentine's Day, it was festive and fun, and a really enjoyable experience. The food was great and came out quickly.