114 Best American Restaurants In Pelee Island

114 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

1. Crush - Sandusky

4.8

Exceptional(738)

$$$$

• American • Sandusky

Booked 8 times today

Food and drinks were absolutely amazing. Our server was outstanding!

2. The Club Sandusky

4.5

Awesome(205)

$$$$

• American • Sandusky

Booked 1 time today

This was the most perfect evening for our group after a conference!!

Icon

3. Selden Standard

4.9

Exceptional(1116)

$$$$

• American • Detroit

Booked 63 times today

Our group of 4 has dined with you at least 4 times this year if not 5! We’ve got one of us with celiac and you’ve always made it a wonderful experience! We love trying all the yummy gluten free options and occasionally not gluten free! The consistency of the food is always outstanding we never leave dissatisfied! Thank you for being a fun exciting place my friends and I look forward to going to in order to celebrate each other!

A photo of The Harbor Kichen & Bar restaurant

4. The Harbor Kichen & Bar

new

3.9

Excellent(5)

$$$$

• American • Port Clinton

Booked 2 times today

We enjoyed our first visit to Harbor Kitchen. They've only been open 1 week, and I think they already deserve high marks. Food was hot and delicious, and servers were gracious as they asked for our patience as the kitchen ramps up for a busy weekend. I look forward to our next visit, which will be soon. Thanks to the team for working so hard to get into a good rhythm. See you soon!

A photo of Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant - Avon, OH - Chester Road restaurant

5. Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant - Avon, OH - Chester Road

4.6

Exceptional(1362)

$$$$

• American • Avon / Avon Lake

Booked 95 times today

Enjoyed our dinner! I did the surf and turf with filet medallions and a lobster tail. Had a dirty nasty martini to go with. My wife had the lobster and shrimp risotto. Both dishes were delicious. Also had the lobster bisque to start. A little different with sort of a tomato base that I highly recommend. Our server Lucy was excellent!!

A photo of The Miller's Table- Sawmill Creek Resort restaurant

6. The Miller's Table- Sawmill Creek Resort

4.6

Exceptional(232)

$$$$

• American • Sandusky

We had a nice dinner at Miller’ Table. The steaks were well prepared but the fish was not to my liking. We enjoyed the delicious desserts. The service was great. In fact, my daughter commented on the genuine hospitality of all of the employees we encountered during our visit. Overall, it was a good experience.

A photo of sarita a restaurant restaurant

7. sarita a restaurant

4.9

Exceptional(2834)

$$$$

• American • Lakewood

Booked 23 times today

This place never disappoints. Always an excellent experience

A photo of Cinco Niños - Sandusky restaurant

8. Cinco Niños - Sandusky

3.7

Very Good(4)

$$$$

• American • Sandusky

Grand opening!!! My kids did not like their chicken quesadillas for some reason. They said it was the chicken.. My mom and I enjoyed the food. The pricing is great! 😊 Will be going again.

9. Strip Steakhouse

4.8

Exceptional(4515)

$$$$

• American • Avon / Avon Lake

Booked 19 times today

I took three work colleagues who had never been there before. Everyone said it was one of the best dinners that they ever had.

A photo of Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant - Toledo, OH restaurant

10. Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant - Toledo, OH

4.7

Exceptional(2361)

$$$$

• American • Toledo

Booked 79 times today

Food is always incredibly here. We had a wonderful time and was treated exceptionally

Best American Restaurants in Pelee Island

Price

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

114 restaurants available nearby

1. Crush - Sandusky

2. The Club Sandusky

3. Selden Standard

4. The Harbor Kichen & Bar

5. Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant - Avon, OH - Chester Road

6. The Miller's Table- Sawmill Creek Resort

7. sarita a restaurant

8. Cinco Niños - Sandusky

9. Strip Steakhouse

10. Cooper's Hawk Winery & Restaurant - Toledo, OH

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable