Best American Restaurants in Edgartown
Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
124 restaurants available nearby
How are Featured results ranked
How is content generated
See what locals rave about
- MMeganHouston •3 reviews5.0Dined 4 days agoA wonderful evening- service was excellent and so friendly!More infoThe Dunes at Winnetu Oceanside Resort$$$$• Seafood• Edgartown•4.5
- JjacquelineGreater Boston •6 reviews5.0Dined 6 days agoWonderful experience…lovely location! We were seated at a table overlooking the harbor. Service was prompt and friendly. The food was fabulous and fresh. What really impressed me was how quiet the restaurant was even with a large group next to us their conversation did not overwhelm us. Given our experience we will be back…your restaurant is a great addition to the dining options in Vineyard HavenMore infoThe Wave$$$$• American• Vineyard Haven•4.1
- AAudieGreater Boston •1 review5.0Dined 6 days agoEverything was perfect. I'd made a reservation on 6/30. Perhaps this is why we were assigned a table at the corner near your dock, with water/boat view for all. The food was good, service was prompt and careful.More infoLandfall Restaurant$$$$• Seafood• Falmouth•4.6
- PPhilipAtlanta •15 reviews5.0Dined on Jun 24, 2026This place is precious. Perfect setting, and one of the rare fine restaurants on Martha's Vineyard where the tables are spaced so that you hear each other speak! Fresh ceviche and intense pasta for starters, then a seared scallop main course that's maybe the best on the island. Wine list is fine but shortened, so lovely Bridget (who runs the place) brought me a computer listing of wines stored below: we found a buttery yet elegant Pouilly Fuissé that went perfectly with our dishes. Despite our appetites already sated, we couldn't resist the lightest of lemon possets to close out the meal. It was my wife's birthday: we wanted the best and we got it.More infoWoods at Lambert’s Cove Inn$$$$• Contemporary American• Martha's Vineyard•4.8
- BBrianGoldMinneapolis - St. Paul •16 reviews4.0Dined on Oct 25, 2025Our server was absolutely awesome! The restaurant is nice, good space, it was busy and pretty loud. The food was good, the portions are very generous. We would come back!More infoMartha's Vineyard Chowder Company$$$$• Seafood• Oak Bluffs•4.3
Discover best American restaurants in Edgartown
Discover the essence of American dining in Edgartown, Cape Cod and the Islands, Greater Boston, where a variety of restaurants capture the spirit of this rich culinary tradition. Each dining spot offers a unique blend of local flavors and classic American dishes, showcasing the area's commitment to freshness and quality. From succulent seafood sourced directly from the surrounding waters to expertly grilled meats and innovative comfort food, the options are both diverse and satisfying. The dining scene in Edgartown is characterized by its elegant yet casual atmosphere, making it an ideal location for both romantic dinners and family gatherings. Visitors can expect exceptional service and a welcoming environment that complements the flavorful offerings. These restaurants not only cater to the taste buds but also to the soul of every diner, promising an unforgettable American dining experience in the heart of Cape Cod. Whether you're a local or a tourist, these culinary establishments are sure to enhance your visit with their distinct charm and high-quality cuisine.