Looking for restaurants with the best overall Italian cuisine in Western New York? You’re in the right place. Each month OpenTable analyzes more than 400,000 new diner reviews. We sort the results by category to help you discover new favorites. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Top ​10 Diners' Choice Winners in Western New York

photo of carmelo's coat of arms restaurant
Exceptional
(388)
97% 97% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Lewiston
Find next available

At the moment, there’s no online availability within 2.5 hours of 7:00 PM. Have another time in mind?

photo of lucia's on the lake restaurant
Exceptional
(1286)
96% 96% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Buffalo
You're in luck! We still have 4 timeslots left.
photo of tempo restaurant restaurant
Exceptional
(1376)
88% 88% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Buffalo
Find next available

At the moment, there’s no online availability within 2.5 hours of 7:00 PM. Have another time in mind?

photo of ristorante lombardo restaurant
Exceptional
(1426)
96% 96% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Buffalo
Find next available

At the moment, there’s no online availability within 2.5 hours of 7:00 PM. Have another time in mind?

photo of amore by wegmans restaurant
Exceptional
(618)
90% 90% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Rochester
Find next available

At the moment, there’s no online availability within 2.5 hours of 7:00 PM. Have another time in mind?

photo of tony d's restaurant
Awesome
(434)
90% 90% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Rochester
photo of carte blanche restaurant
Exceptional
(770)
90% 90% Recommend
$ $ $ $
Italian Hamburg
  • Previous
  • Next