Diners' Choice: Neighborhood gem restaurants in West Cornwall

OpenTable

Updated November 05, 2026

Looking for the best restaurants that are the best neighborhood gems in West Cornwall? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favorite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!

Argoe

4.9

4.9 (440)

£26 to £40

Seafood

Penzance

About the restaurant

Argoe is a harbourside restaurant in Newlyn, a lively fishing hub that has been shaped by its essential industry for centuries, the perfect setting for a restaurant celebrating produce from the sea.

Our menus take inspiration from the coastal cookery of Europe, simple and humble restaurants showcasing the regional ingredients, famers, fishermen and growers that surround them.

Dishes are served to be shared, with a focus on whole fish cooked on our charcoal grill, alongside a wine list highlighting the regions that shape our menus.

Top review

David

Dined 4 days ago

Fabulous as ever. Our new favourite restaurant. We will be back.

Romano's

4.9

4.9 (57)

£26 to £40

Italian

St Ives

About the restaurant

A Neighbourhood Trattoria, in Carbis Bay, just outside the chaos of St Ives. Family run & neighbourhood focused serving seasonal and traditional, not typical, Italian food. We have a real heart for showcasing a side of Italian cuisine and culture that is often lost amongst what's more frequently seen in the Uk.

Seasonal plates paired with a carefully chosen, full-Italian wine list of over 150 wines (on rotation), daily made homebaked bread and desserts. Community and family at the forefront of how we shape our menus. The style of our service reflects this, multiple plates for the table to share, that come when they're ready, in no set order.

Open for coffee and serving fresh made sandwiches for lunch, six days a week, however we only take reservations for dinner.

Top review

Robert

Dined 4 days ago

Enjoyed the friendly atmosphere and selection of Italian meats and cheeses. Provolone with burnt sugar was a great discovery

St. Eia

4.8

4.8 (246)

£26 to £40

European

St Ives

About the restaurant

St. Eia is an intimate restaurant, wine bar & bottle shop tucked away in the back streets of St. Ives, a stone's throw from Porthmeor beach and the Tate Gallery.

We serve seasonal French leaning, bistro inspired food alongside wines which focus on conscientious farming practices and family values.

Daily changing wines by the glass and an ever expanding selection of super rare and exciting wines by the bottle.

Top review

Brian

Dined on Oct 30, 2026

Excellent all round. A gem. I will certainly come again.

Quarterdeck Restaurant

4.8

4.8 (108)

£25 and under

British

St Ives

About the restaurant

We look forward to welcoming you to our lovely Restaurant.

Relax on the outdoor terrace or gaze through the huge windows taking in the awe-inspiring views across Porthmeor Beach and St Ives Bay.

Open daily for Breakfast, drinks during the day and Dinner in the evening, with a take-away service available.

Serving fresh local produce and daily specials we can guarantee a delicious meal with locally produced beers and a hand picked wine list.

We welcome dogs on the outdoor terrace but not in the restaurant.

Please inform us of any dietary requirements and allergies

Top review

PatGold

Dined on Oct 20, 2026

The best restaurant in St Ives! Perfect view and excellent food!

Porthminster Beach Café

4.7

4.7 (5239)

£41 and over

Seafood

St Ives

About the restaurant

Nestled beneath the steep slopes of Porthminster Point, right on the beach with unbeatable and uninterrupted views across St Ives Bay to Godrevy Lighthouse. Now open all year round for lunch and dinner.
Porthminster Cafe in St Ives is a multi award winning seafood restaurant. The atmosphere is relaxed and friendly. The café specialises in Mediterranean and Asian seafood cuisine and is an oasis of taste and visual beauty.
A Holiday in St Ives would not be complete without going to the beach. Here at Porthminster Beach we have one of the cleanest beaches in the South West. We have been given the prestigious Blue Flag Award which guarantees the highest of standards.

Top review

ian

Dined on Oct 27, 2026

Outstanding food. We have eaten here numerous times and always had an excellent experience and fantastic food.

Porthgwidden Beach Café

4.7

4.7 (2501)

£26 to £40

Fish

St Ives

About the restaurant

Nestled beneath the steep grassy slopes of St Ives “Island”, right on the beach with unbeatable and uninterrupted views across St Ives Bay to Godrevy Lighthouse. Now open all year round for lunch, afternoon tea and dinner.

The atmosphere is relaxed and friendly. The café specialises in Mediterranean and Asian seafood cuisine and is an oasis of taste and visual beauty. The café is open daily for a selection of patisserie and the finest coffee.

A Holiday in St Ives would not be complete without going to the beach. Here at Porthgwidden Beach we have one of the cleanest beaches in the South West. We have been given the prestigious Blue Flag Award which guarantees the highest of standards.

Top review

samantha

Dined on Oct 28, 2026

Great food and lovely setting. Service was great too.

Tricky's at The Tolgus Inn

4.6

4.6 (693)

£25 and under

British

Redruth

About the restaurant

Tricky's Restaurant and Bar is a great place to dine. Our large restaurant offers cosy corners for intimate diners as well as space to accommodate large parties. We have created a varied menu to cater for all tastes and budgets. From light lunchtime bites to a hearty three course meal and, there's plenty for the children enjoy as well!

We offer fantastic food, wines, real ales and great service! Combine all these with a warm welcome and you can see why Tricky's is as popular as ever.

We are now open for breakfast Monday - Saturdays mornings between 9-11am.
We also now offer Afternoon Teas Mon - Sat 12-6pm - payment required at time of booking.

When booking please state in the notes if you require seating in our dog friendly lounge area or any specific seating preferences and if we are able to we can seat you accordingly.

Top review

Dianne

Dined on Oct 11, 2026

Excellent service and food. Very friendly and lovely atmosphere.

45 Queen Street

4.6

4.6 (93)

£25 and under

Contemporary European

Penzance

About the restaurant

45 Queen Street is a vibrant, bustling, neighbourhood bar & kitchen, deli & shop that is continually evolving. Open for breakfast, lunch and supper – showcasing local food, cocktails, cold beers, coffee and interesting wines. Specialising in freshly prepared organic vegetables, local seafood, fish, meats and homebaked cakes and pastries.

This spacious, charming warehouse has been brought back to relevance with love and care. Beautifully restored and filled with an abundance of colour and light - to create a space in which everyone is welcomed and looked after. There is also a cosy outside courtyard filled with subtropical plants - the perfect place to enjoy a meal and a cocktail in the sunshine.

With a lively atmosphere, friendly staff, 45 Queen Street is a year round, locals favourite. Nestled in the heart of Penzance, the perfect gateway to visit St.Michaels Mount, the Jubilee pool and Newlyn harbour. If you are visiting the far south west, this is a place not to be missed!

Top review

Jeremy

Dined on Oct 29, 2026

45 Queen Street is the ultimate in a relaxing dinning experience whatever the time of day. Perfect for a date or a catch up with a friend. Delightfully informal and unpretentious. Staff are always great.

Turks Head Penzance

4.5

4.5 (206)

£25 and under

Pub

Penzance

About the restaurant

The Turks Head is the oldest pub in the heart of Penzance town. Unspoiled by contemporary design and décor, this soul-soothing, local pub offers a fresh, seasonal menu coupled with local craft beverages, all of which can be enjoyed in our shanty style, west-country setting. Our secret garden is a hidden retreat that begs for any passing explorer or local Kernow folk to enjoy. Take in the crisp sea breeze blowing in from the Quay just a stone's throw away with a refreshing drink in hand.

Top review

Lisa

Dined 2 days ago

We had t been here for many years, so thought we would give it a try. We were not disappointed. Each of our party of 4 thoroughly enjoyed their meal. Thank you. We will be back. 😋

Discover more

Experience

Festive Set Menu - £38pp (£10pp deposit)

Experience

Sharing plates (£10pp deposit)

The Razor Clam

4.2

4.2 (281)

£25 and under

Seafood

St Ives

About the restaurant

Welcome to The Razor Clam!

This is the place where chefs are putting 100% into creating a unique experience using the freshest ingredients and local suppliers. At The Razor Clam you will be able to find fresh focaccia made by our chefs, ravioli with hand picked crab meat and salmon, a variety of mouth watering pasta dishes and homemade burgers, steaks, risotto and great side dishes. Give us a try and you won't be disappointed.

Hope to sea you soon !!

Top review

Jude

Dined on Oct 11, 2026

We had a wonderful meal as always. The Scallop starter was fantastic and the seafood risotto was packed with fish prawns and scallops. My husband had the homemade burger which he really enjoyed. Portion sizes are very generous and we have never been able to finish on any of the occasions we have been. Excellent quality food and fair prices. Great service from the waitress Mendi who was very friendly and knowledgeable about the dishes on the menu.

Discover more

Explore Diners' Choice best of West Cornwall