Sister Bay Restaurants
Make a free reservation
Restaurant experiences trending in Sister Bay
Check out diners' favorite restaurants in Sister Bay
Updated on
Diners’ Choice Awards are based on where your fellow diners book, dine, and review. Only verified diners get to review restaurants on OpenTable, so our data doesn’t lie.
See what locals rave about in Sister Bay
- CCarrievipMinneapolis - St. Paul •87 reviews5.0Dined 2 days agoWe had a great meal here. Make a reservation. We went at 5 and had the early bird dinner---a great deal with three courses and a moderate choice of entrees. The food is delicious! Yummy popovers. Salmon was great---and hubby liked his upgraded sirloin with garlic butter. Great desserts. Wonderful service. Like this place!More infoCHOP$$$$• Steakhouse• Sister Bay•4.6
- JDJoeDTraderSouthwest Florida •5 reviews5.0Dined 3 days agoExcellent halibut main course. Wonderful tuna nachos -- an innovative, shareable appetizer. Crab cakes small and a bit over fried.More infoLure (WISCONSIN)$$$$• Seafood• Sister Bay•4.6
- KHKarenH1 review5.0Dined 3 days agoAwesome! We will definitely make this a MUST when we are in Fish Creek!More infoBarringer's Restaurant$$$$• American• Fish Creek•4.7
- AAmateurfoodcriticWisconsin •2 reviews5.0Dined on Sep 8, 2023we were looking for the old version of Fat Belly but found they went somewhat upscale and completely changed the menu to a Ramen, Poke and Sushi venue. Completely changed the decor from super casual to a darker and booth atmosphere. Although quite a bit more expensive it all turned out quite good. Especially the pot stickers were a stand out. As it filled up with customers along with the speaker music it started to get quite loud in such a small space. But we would definitely go back.More infoFat Belly$$$$• Asian• Sister Bay•4.8
- OTOpenTable DinerWisconsin •9 reviews5.0Dined on Jan 1, 2023New Year’s Day. Our food was delicious and the atmosphere was beautiful! The waiter was so nice and very informative!More infoChives - Baileys Harbor$$$$• American• Baileys Harbor•4.5
Get inspired by our collections of the top restaurants in Sister Bay
Discover Sister Bay
As one of Wisconsin's premier small-town dining destinations, Sister Bay offers a varied selection of eateries from which to choose. Whether you want to dine at restaurants that have been featured in popular magazines and on the Food Network or try a pub burger at a family-owned tavern, you can easily do so in Sister Bay. You can enjoy waterfront views, local award-winning wines and the popular Wisconsin tradition of a Friday night fish fry using locally caught fish. Speaking of local, there is no better reason to visit than to enjoy the many uses of the famous Door County cherries. There is simply no end to the variations of pies, juices and wines that are produced from the region’s freshly picked cherries.
Frequently asked questions
Dog friendly restaurants in Sister Bay include Lure (WISCONSIN), CHOP and Fat Belly
Explore OpenTable
- Eastside County Park
- Cooks Station
- Pirate's Cove Mini Golf
- Thompsonchristmas Tree Ship Historical Marker
- Sand Point Lighthouse
- Door Bluff County Park
- Eagle Harbor Inn
- Sand Bay Park
- J W Wells State Park
- Shipyard Island Marina Multiple Lifting Facilities
- Saint Jacques Station
- Tot Lot
- Country House Resort
- Jackson Harbor Ridges State Natural Area
- Water Street Gallery
- Edgewater Resort
- Township Park
- Ellison Bay Bluff County Park
- Kenosha Park
- Mink River Estuary State Natural Area