Best Restaurants for Handcrafted Cocktails in Madison

We’ve been there four times now and I’ve enjoyed every single item I’ve ordered. I’m not exaggerating. I really do mean every item from appetizer through dessert, not to mention the Old Fashioned they make smell like a fireplace. The scallop filled stuffing on lobster night is particularly tasty. The wait staff is engaging and personable, often indulging my charming wit. Note: the main room is very (!) loud as it is dominated by the large and lively bar area, often filled with 30-40 somethings coming in after work. However, there is a side room that is nice and quiet if you’re not that animated. Overall … one of our favorite places.

Wonderful. Everyone was kind and accommodating. Frank, the chef, was so welcoming.

Surpassed all our expectations. Best meal we've had in the Hamptons this year. The manager made us feel as if we had been regular customers for years even though it was our first visit. Looking forward to our next meal there.

The food on the Verandah is delicious and you are surrounded by such beauty and not least of which the beautiful sparkling ocean. Unfortunately Ken, the Manager, was off on this our last night. We missed seeing him and Kanesha who is an excellent server. We look forward to a return visit hopefully towards the end of the year

As always, the service was excellent! Surfridge is a friendly, well run establishment with a professional staff and delicious pizza and beer!