23 Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Lancaster

23 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Brick House Tavern + Tap - Amherst restaurant

1. Brick House Tavern + Tap - Amherst

4.6

Exceptional(88)

$$$$

• American • Amherst

Booked 20 times today

Great atmosphere, lots of food options with kids menu. Tons of TVs playing. Quick service

2. 42N at The Flats

4.3

Awesome(142)

$$$$

• Contemporary American • Buffalo

Booked 3 times today

Outstanding! Great atmosphere and great food. Our waitress was wonderful! Definitely recommend!

3. Old Orchard Inn

4.8

Exceptional(167)

$$$$

• Contemporary American • East Aurora

Booked 9 times today

Once again this was a great experience. We will be back again soon!

A photo of Pasquale's Italian Restaurant-West Seneca restaurant

4. Pasquale's Italian Restaurant-West Seneca

4.6

Exceptional(624)

$$$$

• Italian • Buffalo

Booked 3 times today

Excellent Service for our party of 5. All had an enjoyable dinner.

A photo of The Colden Mill Restaurant restaurant

5. The Colden Mill Restaurant

4.5

Awesome(482)

$$$$

• American • Buffalo

Booked 1 time today

This was such a lovely dinner experience! We stopped here on our way from Buffalo to Griffith's Sculpture Park's Night Lights Event and it was the perfect fall dinner stop! We had a steak dinner and one of the pasta dishes and both were awesome! Oh! And we had GREAT old fashions! One was their seasonal Apple Cider Old Fashion and then a second was the classic and both were perfect!

A photo of The Waterfront Restaurant & Lounge restaurant

6. The Waterfront Restaurant & Lounge

4.4

Awesome(576)

$$$$

• Canadian • Niagara-on-the-Lake

Booked 8 times today

Excellent experience and food. Not mention the view.

A photo of Napoli Ristorante and Pizzeria restaurant

7. Napoli Ristorante and Pizzeria

4.8

Exceptional(390)

$$$$

• Italian • Niagara Falls

Booked 9 times today

As always, Napoli Ristorante provides an unforgettable experience with exceptional service and delicious food. It has become a top favourite for family dinners and girls’ nights out, and is by far, my #1 restaurant. The drinks, especially the Manhattan and Hugo Spritz, are unmatched. For food, the Focaccia, Fritto Misto, Gnocchi Osso Buco, and Bianca pizza are some of our go to dishes. Always ensure you leave room for the delicate Cannolis, the mouthwatering Tiramisu, and PERFECTLY hot (and absolutely delicious) cappuccinos. What truly sets Napoli’s apart is the attentive and caring staff who balance checking in with letting guests enjoy their evening. Last night marked the second girls night out in 2 weeks, and we are already planning our next one at Napoli’s for December. Anthony, thank you for always welcoming us to Napoli’s. Jorge, Luis, Janet, Sal, and the rest of the Napoli’s team, thank you for the exceptional service and delicious food. We will certainly be back!

A photo of Milestones Grill + Bar - Niagara Falls restaurant

8. Milestones Grill + Bar - Niagara Falls

4.1

Excellent(1486)

$$$$

• Global, International • Niagara Falls

Booked 11 times today

The view of the falls was really nice, service was very good, the menu had everything that we wanted and the prices was as expected for the location and the view!

A photo of Southern Tier Brewery Buffalo restaurant

9. Southern Tier Brewery Buffalo

4.4

Awesome(32)

$$$$

• American • Buffalo

Booked 1 time today

The Love Island event was so fun! The staff were so friendly and energetic and the themes cocktails were incredible. I had a wonderful time with the contests, decorations, and vibes. :)

A photo of NOTL Bar & Restaurant restaurant

10. NOTL Bar & Restaurant

4.3

Awesome(522)

$$$$

• Comfort Food • Niagara-on-the-Lake

Booked 19 times today

We had a great time at this restaurant, food was great and the best was the service. Peter our server was friendly, gave us great recommendations and make our meal more enjoyable. Highly recommend

Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Lancaster

Price

Cuisine

Regions

Neighborhoods

Top Rated

Dining Options

Seating Options

Accessibility

23 restaurants available nearby

1. Brick House Tavern + Tap - Amherst

2. 42N at The Flats

3. Old Orchard Inn

4. Pasquale's Italian Restaurant-West Seneca

5. The Colden Mill Restaurant

6. The Waterfront Restaurant & Lounge

7. Napoli Ristorante and Pizzeria

8. Milestones Grill + Bar - Niagara Falls

9. Southern Tier Brewery Buffalo

10. NOTL Bar & Restaurant

See what locals rave about

Explore OpenTable