Best Restaurants for Birthdays in Shelter Island
Price
Cuisine
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
74 restaurants available nearby
How are Featured results ranked
Booked 58 times today
Booked 28 times today
Booked 82 times today
See what locals rave about
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- JJasonDallas - Fort Worth •5 reviews5.0Dined 1 day agoExcellent food and bar service; very cool motif! If you want dessert, I suggest splitting it with your date. The banana split is probably enough for 3 people!More infoSugar Factory - Foxwoods$$$$• Contemporary American• Mashantucket•4
- BBrianGoldNew York City •12 reviews5.0Dined 5 days agoOutstanding dinner experience as usual! Everything was on point.👍🏻👍🏻More infoLiv's Oyster Bar$$$$• Seafood• Old Saybrook•4.8
- MMichaelNew York City •5 reviews5.0Dined 7 days agoFrom arrival greeting to last sip of excellent wine offering by the glass our experience was excellent. Over the years David has created a iconic kitchen and culture on the East End.More infoThe Bell & Anchor$$$$• Seafood• Sag Harbor•4.8
- NnancyGoldNew York City •158 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 31, 2026Crab cocktail - off the menu but available by special request. This is the most incredible delight to snack on while waiting for your entree. Every steak is cooked to perfection - best spinach - mashed potatoes - the freshest wedge (a meal in itself) and the service is consistently first class. We also discovered a new wine Reputation. Try it. You won’t be disappointed.More infoThe Capital Grille - Hartford$$$$• Steakhouse• Hartford•4.8
- LlisaNew York City •7 reviews5.0Dined on Aug 16, 2026casual food menu was excellent. Service was GREAT. Music was great as well! Fun venue, We will be backMore infoThe Clubhouse$$$$• Contemporary American• East Hampton•4.6