Diners' Choice: Best Value restaurants in Cape Cod and the Islands
OpenTable
Updated November 05, 2026
Looking for the best value restaurants in Cape Cod and the Islands? You’re in the right place. Each month, OpenTable analyzes nearly 2 million global diner reviews from the past four months. We sort the results by location and category to help you discover new favorite restaurants. It's a great partnership: you reserve, eat, and review. We listen...and deliver the results for all to benefit. Enjoy!
4.9
$50 and over
Contemporary American
Martha's Vineyard
About the restaurant
Restaurant Foster and the Mermaid Bar feature the cuisine of Chef Galen Sampson—whose rustic, locally inspired, and incredibly flavorful dishes are driven by a sense of generosity and respect for farmers and producers. Sampson, in partnership with the hospitality team led by his wife, will leave you feeling satisfied and completely taken care of. Whether you are dining alone, as a couple, or as a larger party, enjoy the sophisticated, but down-to-earth, cuisine and service at Restaurant Foster and the Mermaid Bar in coordination with wines from our carefully curated list. You can dine in our beautiful indoor spaces or in our spectacular English Garden.Our restaurant and bar offer a delightful night-out spot and feature dishes thoughtfully prepared with, when possible, sustainably sourced, on-island ingredients. The Menu provides a sample as to what is served nightly, as it is subject to change.
Please contact us at hello@lambertscoveinn.com about private events.
Top review
R
robert
Dined 4 days ago
About the restaurant
**Having trouble reserving a table online?** Please call us directly at **508.349.2127** — we’re happy to assist!
Peter and Diane Hall, along with Chef Derek, proudly continue Van Rensselaer’s tradition of serving the freshest locally caught seafood, expertly prepared meats, flavorful poultry, and a wide variety of crisp salads. Our homemade sauces and desserts are guest favorites — especially Chef Derek’s renowned Bread Pudding, which earned him recognition as a top Hawaiian baking chef.
We offer two cozy open-air patios with heaters and umbrellas as needed, plus a screened-in porch with eight tables under a covered awning. Inside, our dining room features well-spaced tables dressed in elegant black linen. Our staff is known for its professionalism and warm hospitality.
We’re proud to be **Level 1 Green Certified**, and we invite you to enjoy our newly renovated bar — perfect for dinner or a relaxing drink.
Welcome to Van Rensselaer’s — we look forward to serving you!
Top review
E
EDWARDGold
Dined on Oct 24, 2026
About the restaurant
*Ships Inn is Closed for the 2026 season, we look forward to seeing you in May 2027!*The Ships Inn Restaurant offers one of Nantucket's finest dining experiences. Located in an historic whaling captain\'s mansion built in 1831, the dining room and lounge are below street level and have an updated colonial atmosphere. Tall windows along two walls let in the summer breezes and let escape the sounds of happy conversation. This restaurant is a very good choice for an evening out with friends, and there are cozy, intimate alcoves for more romantic encounters. American/French cuisine is featured, with everything freshly prepared on the premises. Chef Mark Gottwald's food is bold and flavorful, and presented with understated elegance. Dinner menu selections include lobster, calamari, crab cakes, salmon, prawns, chicken, duck, beef, and lamb. Only the freshest ingredients are used. Members of our restaurant staff have been part of the Ships Inn family for an average of seven years or more.
Top review
R
RyanGold
Dined on Oct 8, 2026
About the restaurant
Buca's Tuscan Roadhouse would like to transport you to a favorite trattoria - a little hole in the wall in Tuscany. So, join us, relax, have a glass of wine, a piece of cheese and let your journey begin!Top review
D
Denise
Dined 6 days ago
About the restaurant
Embark on a culinary adventure at Millan's Restaurant in Truro, where global flavors meet fresh, local ingredients. Under the guidance of Chef Carlos Millan and Amparo Carmona, each dish is crafted with passion and precision.
Discover a world of flavors with a diverse menu that includes succulent seafood, vibrant salads, and comforting classics. Enjoy the richness of green curry, the delicate notes of poke bowls, or the timeless fettuccini Bolognese. Whether you’re a vegetarian, seafood lover, or meat enthusiast, Millan's has something to satisfy every palate.
The atmosphere at Millan's is inviting and sophisticated, making it ideal for romantic dinners, family gatherings, or special occasions with friends. With warm lighting, elegant décor, and attentive service, your dining experience will be memorable and fulfilling. Join us at Millan's for a delightful culinary journey.Top review
R
robGold
Dined 4 days ago
About the restaurant
Cast Seaside Bites & Bar in Marion is your coastal escape—where bold flavors, lively cocktails, and a vibrant atmosphere come together just steps from Sippican Harbor.Led by Chef Marc Swierkowski, the menu highlights fresh seafood and shareable plates, including our signature masa fish tacos with housemade tortillas prepared fresh daily. The bar program features creative cocktails, spritzes, and a curated wine list designed to keep the night going.
Enjoy our seasonal outdoor patio or settle into a warm, energetic dining room—perfect for date nights, group dinners, and celebrations that linger a little longer.
At Cast, every visit feels like a night away.
Top review
G
Gerard
Dined on Oct 24, 2026
About the restaurant
LUNE is a one-of-a-kind dining experience on Cape Cod. Nestled in Dennis Port, LUNE hosts an open kitchen experience as a tasting menu ONLY ( Thursday, Friday, Saturday) and a la carte menu ONLY (Sunday).* We kindly ask that you are respectful of our limited onsite parking. We recommend parking at the free Town Municipal parking lot located behind Dickey Insurance Agency (610 Route 28 Dennis Port, MA 02639).
There is also extra parking at Barbo's. To respect our neighbor, we ask you to not park at the Oyster Company or The Pub Next Door!
* Please let us know if there is anyone in your party with dietary restrictions or allergies. These will be accommodated with notice.
*An automatic 20% Gratuity is added to all checks so we can distribute the share fairly.
*Cancellations and modifications to the party size will accepted until 24 hours prior.
*NO SHOWS & DAY OF CANCELLATIONS WILL BE CHARGED THE FULL AMOUNT OF THEIR RESERVATION*
Top review
C
CathyGold
Dined 2 days ago
About the restaurant
Ella's Wood Fired Kitchen in Wareham, MA is a locally loved gem that blends rustic charm with refined flavors. The interior boasts high ceilings, exposed wood beams, and an open wood‑fired oven—a blend of casual elegance and homey warmth. Known for its inventive American cuisine with global influences, Ella's offers wood-fired dishes crafted from seasonal, locally sourced ingredients. From artisanal pizzas and fresh seafood to expertly prepared meats and house-made desserts, every dish reflects a commitment to quality and creativity. Featured in the Boston Globe and seen on Phantom Gourmet, Ella’s is frequently praised for its inventive Italian-American, cozy atmosphere and attentive service. Ella's is the perfect spot for date nights, gatherings, or a memorable dining experience on the South Shore.Top review
R
rebecca
Dined 5 days ago
About the restaurant
Our family welcomes you to join us at Milanos where we serve a variety of authentic Italian dishes made with fresh, high-quality local ingredients. If you can not find a time slot you are looking for for reservations please consider our new 22 seat bar/lounge area which is all first come first served opening at 4pm daily. Things can shift around so just come on in and we will do our best to seat you in the dining room if something opens up! If you need to Cancel your reservation, please do so on Open Table not by calling the restaurant.
Whether you are enjoying us for the first time or a faithful regular, we invite you to come experience our wonderful staff and menu favorites in their new home.
Top review
OT
OpenTable Diner
Dined on Oct 27, 2026
About the restaurant
We warmly welcome you to Leonessa- an Italian-Inspired Kitchen & Bar on beautiful Route 6A in Yarmouth Port. Husband & Wife team, Chef Owner Diego Mota and Owner & General Manager Taylor Amara bring exceptional scratch made regional Italian cuisine and impeccable service to this iconic neighborhood. Combining the best of food and beverage of Italy along with the influences of its bordering neighbors coalesces into a dynamic, modern and elevated culinary experience. Chef Diego and Taylor's dream to pour their true love and passion for food, beverages, and hospitality is realized with every service. Reservations are for tables in each our four unique dining rooms while the Bar welcomes guests on a first come first serve basis. Please note that we do our level best to accommodate seating/area requests but they are not guaranteed. We also kindly ask that parties arrive together so that everyone can enjoy their time with us. Thank You.Top review
C
CaitlinGold
Dined 1 day ago
Explore Diners' Choice best of Cape Cod and the Islands
Explore more Diners' Choice lists