36 Best Sicilian Restaurants In Bayport

36 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Stella Trattoria & Bar restaurant

1. Stella Trattoria & Bar

4.8

Exceptional(1412)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Blue Point

Booked 12 times today

The service was outstanding. Our waitress was Isabel who was perfect with her timing and knew when to check on us and when to leave us be. The only thing to say about the food was just as outstanding as a service. had the stuffed artichokes and the real Valencia. This definitely should be a five star restaurant.

2. Mamma Lombardi's

4.8

Exceptional(777)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Holbrook

Booked 12 times today

Dinner last night at Mama Lombardi’s was absolutely perfect. The ambience was warm, cozy and relaxing. The food was delicious! But what truly made our dinner last night unforgettable was our server Antonio. He was AMAZING!!! He went completely above and beyond for us to ensure everything was perfect. Every single recommendation he made was spot-on. His incredible service combined with the quaint, relaxing ambiance and scrumptious food made for a flawless dining experience. We will definitely be back!

A photo of Satelite Restaurant restaurant

3. Satelite Restaurant

5.0

Exceptional(3)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Bayport

We’ve been here a few times already. The food is excellent with large portions. We love our favorite bartender Amir. We will be back.

A photo of Primi Italian Steakhouse restaurant

4. Primi Italian Steakhouse

4.8

Exceptional(1731)

$$$$

• Sicilian • West Islip

Booked 33 times today

Went out for our anniversary. Had noted on opentable. When we checked in we were greeted with a Happy Anniversary by everyone at the front desk. Same went for the server that got us our water as well as a server that had been helping another table. We were given a really large booth for the 2 of us and were greeted with a glass of champagne by our server John, who was the real MVP. He was attentive without being overbearing. Made sure our night was one to not forget. The food and drinks were fantastic. Shout to the Amalfi, the baby lamb chops and the grilled octopus. Steak cooked perfectly, as was the red snapper that was on special. We were sent off with a complimentary profiterole with house made gelato to end the night. Can’t say enough good things about all involved. Will definitely be back.

A photo of Ficarra Ristorante restaurant

5. Ficarra Ristorante

4.7

Exceptional(135)

$$$$

• Sicilian • Hicksville

Booked 4 times today

From when we valeted the car to when we left service was amazing. Food was off the charts. So many choices and nice size portions. Highly recommend. Smaller restaurant so make sure to have reservations.