138 Best Pizzerias In West Sayville

138 restaurants available nearby

How are Featured results ranked

A photo of Eataly NYC Downtown - La Pizza & La Pasta restaurant

1. Eataly NYC Downtown - La Pizza & La Pasta

4.7

Exceptional(2006)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Financial District

Booked 62 times today

A GREAT location for a regular dinner or for brining friends and family from out of town. The restaurant views are expansive and thefood is high quality as you would expect from Eatly.

A photo of Marys Pizza & Restaurant restaurant

2. Marys Pizza & Restaurant

4.7

Exceptional(61)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • East Islip

Everything was superb! The food is always served piping hot and delicious. The portions are enormous. Our waitress Michele was fantastic. She offered many good food recommendations and also has a great sense of humor! I would highly suggest dining at any one of their restaurants in Farmingdale, Islip Terrace or Speonk.

A photo of Olio e Più – Greenwich Village restaurant

3. Olio e Più – Greenwich Village

4.6

Exceptional(4739)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • West Village

Booked 118 times today

They were very accommodating as our party kept getting bigger and bigger as more people joined. The service provided by Melanie was excellent. Food was delicious and it was very cozy and intimate space for my birthday party.

A photo of Eataly NYC Flatiron - La Pizza & La Pasta restaurant

4. Eataly NYC Flatiron - La Pizza & La Pasta

4.4

Awesome(2813)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • Gramercy Park

Booked 58 times today

Eataly is always such a fun and lively place to enjoy delicious Italian food. Especially the pizza!

5. Marcellino

4.5

Awesome(282)

$$$$

• Pizzeria • SoHo

Booked 5 times today

We found the staff at Marcelino to be very friendly. My daughter’s penne al a vodka was absolutely delicious and the rest of us kept sampling it. My husband and oldest daughter had steak which was excellent. The cocktails were wonderful-we had a Negroni, Aperol spritz and an old fashioned. There was some miscommunication when I ordered salmon and they thought I said “same” as my daughter so they brought me steak, but they corrected. The salmon was good, a little more done than I like. Because of the mix up, they brought us an extra old fashioned on the house and tiramisu! They also didn’t charge us for our Aperol spritz. Nestor was our server and was so kind and accommodating. The location was great, right in the heart of Little Italy and near our Airbnb. The restaurant was cozy, the doors were open but heaters kept us warm. We would definitely go back.