Best Pizzerias in Bay Shore
Price
Regions
Neighborhoods
Top Rated
Dining Options
Seating Options
Accessibility
24 restaurants available nearby
How are Featured results ranked
Booked 33 times today
See what locals rave about
From verified diners like you
From verified diners like you
- DDanielleMiami - Dade •4 reviews4.0Dined 1 day agoMade reservations for 3 people at 7pm. We got there about 5 minutes early and was told it would be about a 30 minute wait still. The owner said we can sit at the bar, wait & we’ll receive 25% off if we stayed bc of the inconvenience. We ended up staying & the food was absolutely fantastic, very nice sized portions as well, fresh. The bartender Angel was so nice and really on the ball with everything. Started off a little disappointing but turned around quickly- the people were extremely friendly, accommodating and all around it was a great experience. The bar is also a great spot to sit and dine !More infoPatrizia's Marquee$$$$• Italian• Commack•4.3
- BBarbieGoldNew York City •24 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 27, 2026I always enjoy the variety of food as well as the taste and presentation. They have specials, weekly or daily. And those are sometimes very delicious. I have been going here since they opened. And continue to bring friends.More infoIavarone Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria$$$$• Italian• Plainview•4.6
- LLauraGoldNew York City •50 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 23, 2026Food was very good. Large portions served. Waitress was attentive to our requests.More infoMarys Pizza & Restaurant$$$$• Italian• East Islip•4.7
- CCathyNew York City •2 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 13, 2026the food is excellent always that’s why we keep coming backMore infoMamma Santina Italian Restaurant$$$$• Italian• Bay Shore•4.8
- PPeterNew York City •12 reviews5.0Dined on Oct 3, 2026Food was amazing as were the portions which we had for dinner the next day too! Order the pastas!!More infoEmilio's$$$$• Italian• Commack•4.6