Best Italian Restaurants in Hyattsville

Price: Moderate (253)Price: Expensive (149)Price: Very Expensive (54)

59 restaurants available nearby

1. Via Ghibellina

4.6

Exceptional(293)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Ivy City

Booked 2 times today

Via Ghibellina is highly acknowledged as serving the finest Italian cuisine accented by exceptional service. Praised by its clientele, it's regarded as "the best Italian restaurant in town" applauded for its "amazingly rich flavors" and "authentic Italian food." Patrons underlined the extraordinary quality of dishes including their handmade pasta like the cacio e pepe and the tagliatelle al ragu, equally celebrated for their excellence. The restaurant's ambiance and warm staff are also lauded. Its menu includes unique items, some of which, according to customers, can only be found in Italy. Via Ghibellina's genuine and high-quality experience is why people are eagerly returning for more.

2. RPM Italian - DC

4.7

Exceptional(4357)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Mount Vernon Square

Booked 104 times today

RPM Italian - DC is acclaimed for its top-tier service, exceptional food, and unique, inviting ambience. Reviewers repeatedly herald it as the best Italian restaurant in the DC area, and even one of the best in the US. From the short rib bolognese to crab bucatini, every dish is crafted to perfection, offering a true taste of Italian cuisine. Its menu is said to be so delicately and masterfully created that you can't go wrong with any choice. Customers keep coming back, making it their preferred spot for celebrating special occasions. The restaurant has been commendably consistent in delivering a fantastic dining experience with a great atmosphere, attentive staff, and most importantly, exquisite food.

A photo of Filomena Ristorante restaurant

3. Filomena Ristorante

4.8

Exceptional(16817)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Georgetown

Booked 262 times today

Filomena Ristorante has been widely praised for its exceptional Italian cuisine, earning it top reviews from patrons who repeatedly return to its Georgetown location. The restaurant is renowned for its high-quality food, attentive service, and wonderful ambiance that transports guests straight to Italy. The authenticity of Filomena's traditional Italian dishes cannot be overstated, with customers describing their meals as "exquisite", "outstanding", "delicious", and even "the best Italian" they've ever had. Reviewers also applaud the restaurant’s extensive wine collection, homemade pasta, and generous portion sizes. The overall experience is one of un-rushed enjoyment, with many planning return visits to relish Filomena's "REAL homemade Italian cuisine" once again.

A photo of Caruso's Grocery - DC restaurant

4. Caruso's Grocery - DC

4.9

Exceptional(1110)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Capitol Hill

Booked 43 times today

Caruso's Grocery in DC has been hailed as a top-tier Italian restaurant, flaunting reviews that commend its traditional Italian menu and unbeatable service. The consistency of excellent service and quality of food are praised and often deemed by locals as a go-to Italian stop. Notable dishes like the rich and flavorful Alfredo and the freshly made shrimp scampi are mentioned as highlights. Furthermore, the restaurant atmosphere is characterized as reminiscent of a family-owned Italian restaurant, enhancing the overall dining experience. The restaurant has reviews mentioning their exceptional food, attentive service, and worthwhile reservation process, proving its worth among the best Italian restaurants in DC.

5. Centrolina

4.7

Exceptional(2040)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Penn Quarter

Booked 51 times today

Centrolina is an Italian restaurant and market, locally owned and operated by Chef Amy Brandwein, set in Washington’s CityCenterDC development. The Osteria showcases a seasonally driven menu of authentic and innovative Italian dishes offered for lunch and dinner. Chef Brandwein's menu is inspired from the seasons, Italian regionality and the wide variety of Chef curated product in the adjoining market. The market showcases a selection of imported Italian specialty items along with locally sourced meat, sustainable fish, and produce from local farms. The Centrolina kitchen produces daily hand crafted fresh pasta and sauces, antipasti and entrees available for takeaway. For parties of 7 people or more, we do require a prix-fixe menu, please email caroline@centrolinadc.com for additional information.

A photo of Lupo Verde - 14th St restaurant

6. Lupo Verde - 14th St

4.3

Awesome(1940)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Logan Circle

Booked 22 times today

Lupo Verde - 14th St has been lauded as a standout restaurant for authentic Italian cuisine. Patrons have praised the eatery for its homemade, fresh, and tasty food offerings, emphasizing the great selection of seafood and meat dishes. The ambiance has also been noted as fun and lively, contributing to an overall enjoyable dining experience. The high-quality service, combined with the excellent food, has led to it being likened to having a good Italian meal in Rome, without the travel. With customers commenting on the outstanding food and service, Lupo Verde - 14th St is a must-visit restaurant for lovers of Italian cuisine. It's been highlighted as one of the best Italian eateries even by New Yorkers, who are known for their high standards. Whether for dinner, brunch, or a special occasion, it never disappoints.

7. Iron Gate

4.7

Exceptional(2954)

Price: Very Expensive

• Italian • Dupont Circle

Booked 30 times today

Iron Gate is lauded as an emblem of fine dining in the realm of Mediterranean cuisine. According to myriad positive reviews, it consistently presents a creatively crafted menu that's described as an "array of flavors beautifully coordinated to a Mediterranean taste delight". Nestled in a beautiful neighborhood in DC, Iron Gate is often referred to as a "gem", thanks to its superb ambiance and the unique flair of its dishes which admirably demonstrate the essence of Mediterranean cuisine. The chef's talent and commitment to a true Mediterranean flair are evident, featuring Italian and Greek dishes and an interesting Mediterranean wine list. Visitors commend the excellent and knowledgeable service, the romantic atmosphere, and the "out of this world" food, specifically mentioning items like the stuffed dates and octopus, which apparently, have left indelible marks on their palates.

A photo of Carmine's - Washington DC restaurant

8. Carmine's - Washington DC

4.4

Awesome(6458)

Price: Moderate

• Italian • Penn Quarter

Booked 45 times today

Located in the heart of Washington DC, Carmine's is known for its authentic Italian food. From the delightful Italian sodas to the extensive selection of wines, the restaurant promises an immersive Italian culinary experience. The menu, offering an array of classic Italian dishes, has been praised by reviewers for its high-quality food. Customers have dubbed it the "best authentic Italian restaurant" they've ever been to. They rave about the excellent service, with special mentions of knowledgeable and friendly staff. The family-style meals have received particular acclaim for their abundant portions, perfect for sharing. From the rave reviews, Carmine's commitment to delivering a genuine Italian dining experience is clear.

9. Tonari

4.6

Exceptional(297)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Penn Quarter

Booked 12 times today

Located in the heart of downtown D.C., Tonari has garnered rave reviews for its innovative fusion of Italian and Japanese cuisine. Patrons are won over by the unique blend of flavors, with many recognizing the exemplary service, quality of food, and overall ambiance. Reviewers particularly highlighted the inventive, yet delicious meals, and lauded the pasta for being perfectly al dente. The restaurant's pizzas were also noted for their light and crispy textures. The unusual flavor combinations and fresh ingredients make Tonari a favorite in the area. With its creative drinks, stellar service, and generous portions, Tonari remains a standout choice for an unforgettable dining experience.

10. Tosca

4.9

Exceptional(4470)

Price: Expensive

• Italian • Downtown

Booked 58 times today

Tosca, a top Italian restaurant in Washington DC, receives consistent acclaim for its excellent food and service. Customers frequently comment on the fresh, delicious meals, with particular praise for signature dishes such as the truffled spaghetti and chicken Milanese. Many diners also note the attentive, friendly staff and the exceptional service they provide. As reinforced by multiple reviews, a visit to Tosca not only delivers an exceptional dining experience but also offers a unique chance to savor some of the best Italian cuisine outside of Italy. Tosca's extensive wine list, featuring fine Italian and Californian vintages, is frequently mentioned and appreciated, adding another layer to the restaurant's authentic Italian experience. Furthermore, Tosca's ambiance is another major highlight, contributing to the overall pleasure of dining at this outstanding restaurant.

‘About the restaurant’ descriptions have been generated using an artificial intelligence model comprised of OpenTable proprietary data that has not been independently verified by OpenTable. The content is presented as-is, for informational purposes only.

Explore OpenTable

Hyattsville

Italian