Best Comfort Food Restaurants in Oconomowoc

Three of us had dinner and, as always, it was exceptional! Service was excellent and we had Mason as our server. He was attentive, knowledgeable and answered any questions we had. Appetizers were fabulous. The main dinner was incredible. Two of us had the large, prime filet. It was done perfectly per our request at medium rare. It melts in your mouth. The other had the jumbo shrimp which also were excellent. The menu is great with plenty of choices. A perfect place for any dinner.

We Love the happy hour & enjoyed sitting at the bar for excellent choices of food & drinks! Emily the bartender is the best! Great sense of humor & her service & knowledge is impeccable! We always look forward to coming back to town that includes one night at Red Circle Inn! It’s our “date night” after seeing family & friends in the area.

A truly unique and delicious experience. I would definitely go back the next time in Milwaukee.

We had a wonderful dinner at Buckley's. We were seated at a window table in the old bar room per my request. Our server, Kelly, was kind and professional. The cocktails were delicious and the empanadas were superb! Such a cozy and perfect spot.

Finally discovered Safina after dining in Milwaukee theater district for the last 5 years. Everything was top notch from prompt attentive service, accommodating vegetarian options, and delicious meals. Will definitely return.